“Men trip not on mountains, they trip on molehills” – Chinese
proverb
A dear friend in response to my last musing had requested
that I put some thoughts or research a bit more on the idea of redistribution
of wealth. I may not be the right person
to talk about it because in the first place I do not have that kind of wealth
that people would focus on these days; secondly, it is not what keeps me
awake at night since I don’t have that much to redistribute to begin with. Economists
have spent copious amounts of time on it already and when ten of them are put
in a room we can and will get ten different answers. However, what I lack in advance degrees in
economics is more than made up for with an idle mind that tries to imagine what
it would be like to be wealthy and urged that I need to share that in some
arbitrary manner. Imagination, which is
probably the only form of entertainment one gets for free these days, is what
the idle mind will engage in.
Let’s imagine a landscape where mountains make up two per
cent of the area and the rest is all molehills.
Inhabitants of molehills complain that the top of the mountains gets the
rain first and seem to be getting a lot more of it; furthermore, it was pointed
out that the mountain inhabitants seem to be the only ones to touch the clouds
and they’re so much closer to the stars and the moon. The up-landers as they’re called by the
low-landers are enjoying more than fair share of the resources.
One day the low landers decided that the mountains should be
torn down despite the fervent entreaties from the up-landers who say that much
of the rain that falls on them goes all the way down as runoffs through the
mountainsides anyway. The mountaintops
can retain only so much. Nevertheless,
the low landers won and the mountains were leveled to the height of molehills.
The landscape changed and so did the weather patterns. Wind streams carry cold and moist air
flow through in the upper atmosphere and with no mountains to impede the flow
or trap the moisture or cause the clouds to swirl and get heavy, the rain
stopped coming. The land below turned
from lush to barren landscape. Now we know why there are mountains and yet
though they make up only a small percentage of the surface of the earth we
cannot and should not even be thinking of leveling them down.
Another metaphor is probably more fitting. It took tremendous geological forces,
upheavals of unimaginable energy from underground, and eons of time to create
those mountains. A business is built up
the same way by people who chose to sacrifice their own personal lives and
often to the detriment of their family well-being by spending the bulk of their
energy and time to build up a molehill.
Sometimes they get lucky and up come a mountain. Now you know how a classic cliché is turned
upside down to a better light.
Let me stay with mountains for a while. Physicists and geologists who have as much
ample idle time as I do but with more sophisticated technical clout have
calculated and declare that there is only so much height earth mountains can go
up. Their own weight (gravity) alone
will limit their growth as the base can only take so much before giving way and
there is wind and water erosion and the occasional earthquakes and volcanic
activity as the other contributing factors.
Businesses can only increase in size up to a certain point because
forces like competition, regulations, taxes and demographics act just like
gravity and the erosive powers of wind and water. In the U.S., anti-trust laws prohibit
monopolies and in most cases competition and regulations provide the best check
and balance to the benefit of consumers.
Still we worry that certain mountains are way too high.
Billionaires do not keep their wealth under mattresses. Much of their money does run off the sides of
the mountains. If it’s not re-invested
it goes to acquiring yachts and Lamborghinis.
Let’s think for a minute about the number of people ship builders and
car companies employ. Let’s go back to
the 1400s when Columbus embarked on what seemed like a frivolous ocean cruise
financed by Queen Isabela. The “Maria”,
“Pinta” and the other ships whose names escape me were built by several hundred
people whose livelihood, if not for the entrepreneurial spirit of the early
seafarers, would have been relegated to building dugout canoes as their
ancestors have done. Today ordinary wage
earners get to enjoy luxurious vacation trips even if only for a week because
investors put money on shipyards to build super cruise ships. Otherwise, we would still be paddling canoes
through rivers and streams. Not that
there is anything wrong with that but we get better food and accommodation when
we cruise and see more places in a week than Lewis and Clark saw in half a
year.
Where there are mountains small outfitters sell mountain
climbing equipment and apparel. Tourists
come to offer their oohs and aahs, take pictures with their fancy digital
cameras and boost local economy at hotels, restaurants and the ubiquitous
tourist traps. Would they have come if
there were only molehills around?
Let’s leave the mountains alone and let some molehills grow and
aspire to become one. The garage where
Jobs and Wozniak started Apple, or the shack where Hewlett and Packard came up with
their first scientific calculators, were molehills that went sky high. Sam Walton started with a few molehills that
went nowhere until Wal-Mart and Sam’s Club took hold. Let’s not forget however that only few mountains
will rise from molehills, just as there could only be a handful of NBA stars or
major league baseball players from thousands of aspirants. But we do not spread Michael Jordan’s points
among his team mates, do we?
This was obviously not Econ 501 in-depth analysis and I may
have exceeded the legal amount of metaphors in a single note but I hope the
visual images of molehills against the backdrop of “purple mountains majesty”
are clear enough.