The Prez and Perfecting the Art of Doublethink
Today is 1984 plus thirty years. 1984 has reference, of course, to George
Orwell’s novel of the same title. It was
written in 1948 and meant to discuss what it would be like living in 1984. By the way, although Orwell meant for the
novel to take place in the future he did not initially want for the title to be
that, but apparently someone suggested that perhaps a permutation of ‘48, which
was the year he conceived the novel’s idea, 1984 was a clever title; although
the book was actually finished and published in 1949. Well, the year 1984 as we
now know did not quite live up to the futuristic world that Orwell had in
mind. 2014, however, comes close, to wit,
the NSA’s capacity and will, the propagation of information through the web and
the willingness of the people to do Facebook, twitter, and passive nonchalance
towards privacy. But I set that aside to
make room for something that is not as well known about the novel, at least not
to those who have not read the book but are quite familiar with the concept of
“Big Brother”.
The novel talked about “Newspeak”,
as “the method for controlling thought through language; doublethink is the
method of directly controlling thought.”
“Doublethink means the
power of holding two contradictory beliefs in one's mind simultaneously, and
accepting both of them.”
― George Orwell, 1984
“To know and not to
know, to be conscious of complete truthfulness while telling carefully
constructed lies, to hold simultaneously two opinions which cancelled out,
knowing them to be contradictory and believing in both of them, to use logic
against logic, to repudiate morality while laying claim to it, to believe that
democracy was impossible and that the Party was the guardian of democracy…”
-
Also a quote from the novel
In no way am I concluding that the President is
intentionally doing it as a matter of strategy or using it to prop up an agenda
but I do suggest that his education and life’s experiences were shaped by his
chosen world which had allowed and encouraged this method of driving across
one’s ideology, where one with a gift for oratory can use successfully. And the mindset of a former college professor
provides the right breeding ground for that.
If we listen carefully to his speeches (the recent one being at West
Point Commencement Address), or read some of his writings, or even if we were
to dissect his answers during press conferences, he almost always takes two
opposing opinions or ideas by himself and then oftentimes find himself getting
lost in what he is trying to say. It
will only serve to lengthen this note to quote many of his doublespeak but if
you are diligent, a quick Google search has many examples of it.
Here’s one recent example of what he said at West Point, “Here’s my bottom line: America must always
lead on the world stage. If we don’t, no one else will.” A few sentences later he followed with this, “On the other hand, when issues of global
concern that do not pose a direct threat to the United States are at stake –
when crises arise that stir our conscience or push the world in a more
dangerous direction – then the threshold for military action must be
higher. In such circumstances, we should not go it alone. Instead, we must
mobilize allies and partners to take collective action.” So, in this quote alone he acknowledged a
condition that could “push the world in a more dangerous direction”. Now, how does that not pose a threat to the
U.S.? To assess it as either a direct or indirect threat to America smells of
doublethink. And how successful has his
foreign policy been with mobilizing allies?
It’s not been good, particularly when his administration’s policy speaks
to “leading from behind” – another doublethink.
We can ascribe it to human nature, of course. I’ve thought of it because today I was at the
home center (commonly, a hardware store) looking for a shutoff valve
replacement for a bathroom fixture. I
did not have the old part with me because, well, it meant shutting off the main
water supply. Not exactly a viable
option when there are other people at home who may need to use water while I
was gone shopping for a part. So I asked
the plumbing guy who promptly asked back if the pipe I was connecting to was
copper or galvanized iron pipe. It was
hard to tell because there was a nickel-plated sleeve over the pipe coming out
of the bathroom wall to the valve. The
plumbing guy said, “Well, it’s actually one or the other of the two valves”, so
I bought the two and intended to install what fits when I got home and return
the other. The President somehow also
seems to always buy two of anything; unfortunately, in foreign policy or the
running of a government, one can’t always return the other and sometimes
neither fits. That is the peril of
doublethink.
College professors use that technique to train or get their
students to consider two or multiple sides of an argument. Well and good, but that process should only
reside in the classroom because real life is not as forgiving. When the President says that there are
consequences if another leader crosses a red line but does nothing when it
happens then the theoretical is consequently and suddenly shattered by reality.
Think about it. But, don’t doublethink it.
No comments:
Post a Comment