Featured Post

“Mountains to Molehills”

“Men trip not on mountains, they trip on molehills” – Chinese proverb A dear friend in response to my last musing had requested tha...

Monday, June 9, 2014

The 2nd to the Last Word on Global Warming/Climate Change



In yesterday’s news was this:  “White House adviser John Podesta told reporters Monday afternoon that Congress could not derail the Obama administration’s efforts to unilaterally enact policies to fight global warming.”

Before the government gets the last word I thought I’d put in the penultimate …

The 2nd to the Last Word on Global Warming/Climate Change

Remember the Y2K hysteria that gripped the world at the turn of the century?  The band wagon of predicted calamity and mass disorder was ridden by some of the most intelligent and learned folks from academia, bureaucracies, and corporations – virtually the ABCs of the world that mattered – that gave new meaning to the phrase, “cost was no object” to preserve and continue the proper functioning of businesses, industry and government. The impending disaster required the single minded mobilization of the electronically driven world.  Debates went on prior to and post the first year of the new millennium.  So much money and manpower were spent, although many argued against it before and soon after, but perhaps only a fraction of it should have been spent.  As it turned, not only was the impact of the Y2K bug over estimated, the budget allotted was way out proportioned because localized and specialized steps could have been all that were needed.  That’s what hindsight tells us now and the good news was that the predicted disaster, like many dated prophecies of doom, had a shelf life limited to a specific date.  After which, calmer methods were applied to assess and unravel the mass hysteria.

The bad news for anyone who wants to apply an ordered assessment of global warming and climate change is that for this particular predicted disaster, there is no specific date on the calendar to mark its shelf life.  As a matter of fact, it has an almost limitless reach into the future and the fear has the ability to morph itself into something else.  When global warming started to cool in people’s minds we now have climate change.  The latter is more insidious, of course, because it covers both sides of the temperature chart.  It is very difficult to argue against or present a specific response when, “if it gets too hot we have a problem and when it gets too cold we have a problem”.

If an extra-terrestrial alien observer from far, far away is making an assessment of the problem by reading dispatches on the impending disaster it must be led to believe that everyone on earth must live in a nice temperate climate that are defined as in between 23.5 degrees to 50.5 degrees north and south latitudes.  Surely, nobody lives along the equatorial zones or up and down the Arctic and Antarctic regions. The alien must note that if earthlings are worrying about a degree or two of temperature increase or decrease in world temperature their fragility is noteworthy (just in case they decide to come for a closer look into the wimpy world of worriers).  They will have to preclude the existence of people, let alone other living things, in equatorial places like Papua, New Guinea, the Kalahari or the Galapagos (and surely nobody goes to Palau), or Siberia or Alaska or Alberta, Canada. The alien will likely have looked into earth’s history of several mass extinctions that have occurred due to natural but major climatic changes for millennia in the past and marvel at the diversity of life today.  They must know of the phenomenal adaptation that life has taken on in the face of tectonic upheavals, volcanic activities, meteor bombardments – to name a few – and that does not include the ravages caused by unseen organism that brought the black plague, Spanish flu and small pox and the savagery of wars.  Surely, the alien monitor will understand how adaptable humans are but might find it perplexing that they seem so overly concerned about a degree or two in climate variation.

After going through all media broadcast from earth, scientific data, Al Gore’s power point presentation, the movies, and behavior of the worriers, the extraterrestrial watcher will have this on her/his/its report:

1.      It is estimated that life on earth has existed for 3 billion years for simple organisms but only a few hundred million for more complex life forms and only for about two hundred thousand years when the first humans appeared. Organisms have been very resilient and highly adaptable over many variations of climate changes that lasted for hundreds and hundreds of years.  Geological record indicated at least five ice ages that lasted for many hundreds of years each.  Organisms died out but those that survived were many times better than their ancestors.  Question: If earth temperature changes 2 degrees hotter or cooler will organisms survive?  Yes, and likely even better adaptable, based on historical and genetic records and how they are doing today.  A five degree change is very extreme and will take several thousand if not millions of years to happen.  During that time earth will have had other and far worst serious problems brought upon it other than climate change.  As in the past, however, life will prevail due mainly to the fact that the changes took eons to reach either their highest or lowest levels.

2.      There is not enough water on earth at the present moment, even if a good fraction of the polar ice caps melt to completely inundate many human settlements around the globe, including Manhattan, NY.  The fear ranges from the ocean swallowing up the Maldives (a Pacific island republic that is only 1.5 meters above sea level, where its highest point is only 2.4 meters) to the worst case scenario depicted in one earth movie, Waterworld, where all of earth has become a global ocean, and the peak of Mt. Everest is the only island left.  For that to happen more water would have to have been introduced extra-terrestrially, such as a bombardment of several thousand ice-y comets each the size of one Mt. Everest.  In which case, earth would face far worst problems than global flooding.

3.      We have a good understanding of natural and scientific data from earth.  Where we lack the most is in understanding human culture and human nature.  Humans are at the top of the food chain, the only truly thinking species and fully self-aware.  We wholly expected an even distribution of positive and negative attitudes but apparently the alarmist voice is louder.  Not that there is anything wrong with it but the alarmists seem to say but, by far, do less than what they are saying. There is an organization, The Sierra Club, that espouses care for the environment and very much concerned with man-made climate change.  Well and good but should their leaders be driving around in large gasoline consuming vehicles (fondly called SUVs) and a few Jaguars (gas guzzling cars)?  Should Al Gore and the actors and actresses from their movie industry talk about man’s profligate behavior, all the while flying in their private jets and drive around in SUVs that leave tons of CO2s in the air in a few short trips – more than the entire emissions generated in a typical rush hour in small town USA for a month?  Should they be living in 10,000 to 20,000 sq. ft. homes that consume five to seven times the energy of an average U.S. home every day but for half of the year they are somewhere else – or, anywhere with a private airport?

4.      Question: Why did living organisms, including humans, survive the many episodes of major climatic changes that have visited earth over eons?  Answer: The climatic changes did not happen overnight so organisms (the survivors) adapted.  Lower life forms did not have the intellect and neither had the early humans been equipped with sophisticated technological tools but they all managed.

5.      Best estimate for earth’s capacity to sustain life depends on the following: (a) its sun, as in all solar systems that harbor life, will dictate earth’s viability, and it is estimated that it has one to two billion years left to provide adequate life-sustaining energy; (b) Unsustainable population growth coupled with depletion of resources and energy; (c) Diseases, natural disasters, military conflict and breakdown of society; and (d) Extra-terrestrial events nearby from supernova explosions to asteroid collisions.

6.      The fervor, energy and call for so much resource to fight climate change may be best used towards ways and means for adaptation to, rather than fighting, climate change.  Feeding the growing world population should be foremost. A 2-degree warming could create more arable lands in places too frigid for crops.  Imagine the millions of acres for agriculture in Siberia, northern Canada and other places (Greenland may even live up to its name).  An ice age could lower the water levels around the equatorial region, the same phenomenon that created land bridges in the past, so more arable land will be exposed as well.  These changes will occur gradually (as in multiple hundreds to thousands of years) so there is ample time for adaptation and migration – the very same thing that had occurred more than four times in earth’s history.

7.      While much of the concern for the environment is very anthropocentric, though more so in the first than the third world countries, humans hold only a fraction of the tenancy of the earth.  Furthermore, the landlord – earth, the environment, mother-nature, if you will – in a much larger sense shapes the lives of its tenants rather than the other way around.  Earthlings will be best served by lowering the tone and curtailing the reach of those who preach fear for profit and allow for equal voices from those who offer a different view for a balanced discussion. 

Conclusion:  Earth, like all the habitable planets around a star system that we have studied, will have predominance over its climate, environment and the fate of everything that resides on it.  It had been around by itself for 99.9% of the time that had elapsed so far before living organisms came to be and it will still be around long after every living organism has ceased to exist. Every living thing has temporary tenancy while the earth is the landlord but only a part of a community that is powered by its sun that is one of about two hundred billion swirling around an average size galaxy that is one of a hundred billion in the known universe. Humans who profess to understand are lined up at either side of the debate while the majority of the earth’s population  do not get to participate in the discussion but they have a far greater respect for the mystery of the universe and its Creator that we ourselves, a more advanced civilization, have been hard pressed to understand.  This planet that is the subject of this report is faced with too many variables, far beyond what its inhabitants can control so that the voices of those who claim to understand are just that - voices.


You, my dear reader, will and must have the last word on the subject.  Speak it well and loudly.

No comments:

Post a Comment