That is not a randomly picked
number. It is both what makes and how democracy works; but it is also a curse. Whoever were the early thinkers
who came up with the idea of democracy were inspired by the thought that when
people were involved in running their government the rule of the majority must
prevail. It is reasonable to suspect
that their idea of a majority at that time may have ranged between 75 to
100%. It is natural to expect that something so profound an idea had to evolve
over time; but, as evolution goes, can we say that it is taking us and every
other country that subscribes to the system to a better place? Indeed, if today you can gather one hundred
people to decide on one serious issue and you get 51 of them to go one way and
the remaining forty nine veer the other direction you will be hard pressed to
call that a resolute or purposeful decision, let alone a hell-bent mandate. The
U.S. can claim, perhaps by self-allusion, that it is the showcase of modern
democracy that other nations can look up to but let’s get some hard data in a
little bit but first a quick background check on this system.
Demos and kratos
are two Greek words where democracy came from. Demos for people, the
citizenry, hence we have demographics, demonstration, demagogue, etc. and kratos
for rule or power, hence we have bureaucrats, aristocrats, technocrats, etc. Greece
was then not only the birthplace of philosophy and logic it became the center
for higher learning where mathematics and the sciences advanced in unprecedented
pace. Political science came along as
well. The population was not huge but people participation in government may
have been a lot more involved than casting a vote once every few years as in
today’s modern democracy. However, it
was likely logical then for the electorate to think that for every given one
hundred people, seventy was a natural majority but sixty would have constituted
a tolerable compromise. Certainly, if it
began as a direct participatory practice of democracy it soon evolved into a
more representative system when the Romans adopted it. The Roman senate thus
became the early symbol of representative government entrusted to a handful of
toga-garbed politicians.
Now, where are we in the
evolutionary ladder of democracy?
Let’s do the numbers. We do not have final data on the last 2016
election but we do have for 2012 based on Federal records:
Let’s examine that because it is the basis for this musing.
From all of those numbers a total of 129 million votes cast
may look impressive but not really. According to the 2012 Census Bureau there
were 235.2 million eligible voters. A good 45.2% did not bother to go the
polls. That is not a trivial non-participation number.
The last time this country had
witnessed an overwhelmingly unified electorate was in 1980 and 1984 when Ronald
Reagan won 489 electoral votes from 44 states and 525 electoral votes from 49
states, respectively, in two consecutive elections. Compare that to Bill Clinton’s wins of 370
and 379 electoral votes in 1992 and 1996 respectively and majority of the popular
votes of 57 and 51 per cent each time.
G.W. Bush won with the thinnest of margins – 271 and 286 in two
elections and just barely over 50% of the popular votes. Pres. Obama won for
two terms – 365 and 332 electoral votes but a mere 54% and 51% respectively in
popular votes. In other words in the last 28 years of electing presidents the
voters were split almost evenly with each winning candidate garnering the
majority in the low 50s percentile. Three elections were in fact won with just
51% of the popular votes.
In 2012 Pres. Obama won his
second term with 51.06% of the popular votes, where Gov. Romney took 47.20%.
The gap is due to the fact that there were 27 other candidates and a slice of
write-in votes. The latter was a negligible number relatively speaking but
there were still 136,040 folks who did exactly write someone else’s name or
perhaps even their own. The two major independent candidates who ran again in
2016 took in 1.3% (Johnson and Stein combined in 2012). Not to be ignored was
the fact that comedienne Roseanne Barr got the fifth largest number of votes
representing the Peace and Freedom Party. Her TV fans of the popular show,
Roseanne that ran from 1988 to 1997 obviously did not show up except for the
67,326 who wrote her name.
2016 election results once again
brought to the surface the debate over the electoral
versus popular votes that pops out
from time to time over the course of many elections. More so this year because
of a call for recounts by Jill Stein’s campaign and now joined by Sec.
Clinton’s own. But that is not what we need to get into here because there is
something more intriguing, yes, even more than a recount.
Election strategy naturally
evolved over time but more importantly with the changing social environment,
population make-up and information technology the evolution is something the
Founding Fathers had not anticipated. This new phenomenon is exposing
democracy’s weakest point. It may even further fuel the debate between
proponents of the constitutionally prescribed Electoral College and those who want
a straight up popular vote; however, if we focus our attention on that we are
missing something truly important.
What else do those numbers tell
us? Perhaps we may never see a repeat of
1980 and 1984 which could very well have been the last
truly-overwhelming-majority election. Since then the electorate was split almost
down the middle, each side decidedly entrenched but for a sliver of
independents in between. There is no
question that there really are independent voters, a good portion of them
perhaps deciding at the last minute, but what gives pollsters real headache is
determining (a) how many genuine independent voters are there really; (b) where
and how do you find them; (c) how does a campaign identify the mood of these
voters ahead of every election. The latter is the trickiest one because
obviously no two elections are alike, so how does one find out what clicks with
these independents from one election to the other.
Let’s look at a theoretical, if
also a hypothetical, campaign where two candidates are running for sheriff in a
county of 100 families spread out over a 100 square mile rural area. Let’s
assume that the two candidates each has a pretty good hold on 40% each of the
voters (let’s say because of friendships, familial relations, and other
affiliations through clubs or churches). Each has a set budget, time and energy
to run their respective campaign. It is
only reasonable that each candidate will focus their attention on the remaining
20% of the families that are not part of the 40% that each already has;
otherwise, it is political malpractice to spend money and energy on all 100
families, especially when one only needs to get 51% of the 20%, thus getting the extra 11%, to win the
election.
If you can tolerate a few extra
doses of cynicism, let’s protract the above theoretical campaign further. Suppose those two candidates are no longer
around after a couple of decades or a generation past 1984; what will be the
strategy of the candidates currently vying for votes from the same 100
families? Given the same budget and time constraints they need to narrow their
campaign. So, why not divide the
constituents into two distinct groups, (let me be facetious here), i.e. those
who farm versus those who ranch, pick-up truck owners versus SUV drivers, etc.
Identify with one group, demonize the other and focus on anyone in between. A cynical view as this might seem, this is
what has been happening in the U.S. democracy today since 1984.
Divide and Conquer may seem like a tired cliché but that had become the antithesis of unity that democracy is supposed to bring. You see, a divided country is not split exactly and sharply
down the middle to the zero decimal place. A candidate only has to have 51% or
even as close as 50.1% of the electorate for him or her to win an election.
Why does one candidate insist on
a strategy of dividing the voters by gender, by economic class, by education,
adhering to political correctness against those deemed politically insensitive,
and identifying one side with every –ism
there is, etc.? It’s been working
because by dividing the nation one is assured of holding on to the base and
therefore can focus on just winning 11% or higher from those in the middle – “the independents”.
Now, there is a certain myth that
shrouds the phenomenon of the independent
voter, I surmise. Independent may not be what it actually is. It could
actually be a hybrid of folks who lean one way, either Republican or Democrat,
at the outset but are persuadable to go the opposite way when going to the
polls, perhaps at the last minute. In
other words these folks normally think as conservative or liberal from either
party as Republican or Democrat. Under ordinary circumstances with all things
being equal (if that is ever possible, or at least when issues are not earthshakingly
divisive), these Democrats or Republicans will cast their ballots often for their
party, say, 7 out of 10 elections until the balance is tipped for change and
the cross over occurs. Even so called Libertarians, including those
un-registered with either of the major party, do not live in a vacuum. No
individual can ever claim to be free of biases. They can label themselves with
whatever affiliation but they must have a particular bias one way or the other
which leans either conservative or liberal.
It is therefore not unreasonable
to suspect that these hybrid independents will lean one way or the other at the
last minute, if you will, but the net effect could only be between 5-10 %. That
number shows up in surveys that lead pollsters to assume that independents make
up about anywhere from 5-15%. It is possible that that is just the net effect
of the crossing over of these hybrid independents – meaning that when you take
the difference between the Republican and Democrat leaning hybrid voters who
switch from time to time, that is the number you get. This leaves politicians
today, since after Reagan, with a particular strategy. Why
did it fail in 2016?
The failed candidate lost for a
host of different reasons but defining one sector of the electorate as a “basket of deplorables” perhaps severely
crossed the sensitive dividing line. On
the other hand, the other candidate who perhaps had the deficiency of main
stream media support, created his own electronic newspaper where he was the
editor-in-chief with just one regular column that did not exceed 140 characters,
composed of common words, simple grammar and easily understood message, sent
out even in the wee hours of the morning.
It is obvious too that
geographically speaking the East coast and West Coast go exclusively one way
and a few Midwest states with a large urban population tag along with them, for
the most part until this last election.
This brings us to the debate over Electoral College versus popular
votes. First of all, the Electoral
College is here to stay so any debate will only go into the bin of forgone
conclusions. Second of all, future
candidates will only change their campaign strategy if elections are determined
by popular votes. The conditions will remain the same. The key is whether one party will continue to
suffer from ideological and cultural erosion as they did this last election. The
idea that regulations to control private sector behavior and expand government,
the preoccupation with political correctness, the continued condescension
towards those who “cling to their guns and religion” and the rural blue collar
workers, and an elitist attitude of “we know what’s good for the rest of the
population”, etc. will need the party's re-visitation instead of laying blame on
communication and lackluster campaign when the problem was primarily with the message
and a messenger who did not really connect with a good portion of their 40%
base.