Featured Post

“Mountains to Molehills”

“Men trip not on mountains, they trip on molehills” – Chinese proverb A dear friend in response to my last musing had requested tha...

Tuesday, June 10, 2014

Income Inequality and the Ninety Nine Cannibals and One


Income Inequality and the Ninety Nine Cannibals and One
I imagined a story that ran this way.  In a very remote island lived a hundred people; 99 of whom were cannibals and one who was not.  One day by an overwhelming majority the 99 decided to make a meal of the one who was not.  End of story.
The longer version went like this.  The island at first had ample resources and all of the hundred people got along well.  Then one day food supply on the island started to dwindle. The non-cannibal had seen to it that he found other ways to feed himself outside of what can just be found on the island by fishing from the sea. So he stayed healthy and looked well while the 99 looked emaciated as food supply diminished. Then one critical day the 99 looked to the one who was healthy and by a unanimous vote decided to sub-divide him into 99 equal parts. In the eyes of the 99 it was well justified that one was sacrificed for the survival of the many.  99 were fed.  For one day.  End of story.
Then there was this version. The one who was not a cannibal employed a few of the 99 to help with fishing.  Soon half of the cannibals were working for him and they were well provided for, so that, as a result and by consensus, they and the non-cannibal gave part of what they earned to those who neither worked nor earned anything.  (Is that where taxes came from?) Meanwhile, from the 99 arose a leader who declared that they deserved better and promised that he will see to it that everyone gets fair share of everything that was gathered from the sea.  Furthermore, the non-cannibal who had the most must give more than those who worked for him; in fact, it was so that at the end of the day he was not to have more than what everyone else had.  Since he was outnumbered the non-cannibal agreed.  As days went on those who worked deliberately did less and less as it was pointless to work any harder since they will end up with the same as everyone else - until ultimately only the non-cannibal was fishing.  Then one day when there was no longer enough for everyone, the 99 looked to the One and made a meal of him. For one day.  End of story.
The moral of the story, if there was one, was that opportunities may be equally available to everyone, perhaps even guaranteed, but not everyone will want to avail of it.  And even for those who do, equal results are not guaranteed.  Come to think of it, there is really no moral to the story.  For the 99 and the 1, it is the same sad “End of story”.
The question is why this whole idea of income inequality as a central theme for discussion in both the political and social scene is baffling.  I know the proponents are not suggesting that everyone should have equal income; at least, I hope that’s not what they’re saying.  What are they saying?  Well, it seems that they want those with less income to get more through some kind of system whereby the ones with more need to give a little more than what they’re giving now in terms of taxes so that the government may re-distribute it to those with less.

Income inequality should be a real and acceptable state in any social or political system.  A proper functioning society allows for that state but that it must also allow for equal opportunity for every individual to earn as much as he or she can, according to his or her ability and willingness to work for it. This system is actually necessary for society to exist and thrive because it would require that different people will have to do different roles, the latter will always be unequal.  To do those roles will also mean that some will pay well and others not as much.  For example, certain roles will require more skill or education to do so those will be paid more than those that require less.  The important thing is that anyone who aspires for the better paying roles will have the same opportunity to do so for as long as that person is willing to put in the time and energy to learn the skill and acquire the education to be able to do those roles.  However, it will never be a perfect system because every individual will be different.  Even in a society made of clones, its proper functioning would still require that roles are not always equal, hence, will have unequal pay.

No comments:

Post a Comment