Featured Post

“Mountains to Molehills”

“Men trip not on mountains, they trip on molehills” – Chinese proverb A dear friend in response to my last musing had requested tha...

Tuesday, April 5, 2016

The Self Inflicted Termination of a Democracy?


This will seem drastic, even a fatalistic  view of what is seen around the world as a self-ascribed showcase model of a nation born of pure idealism that is anchored in individual freedom but subscribing to the rule of the majority. Granted democracy is a human invention, the ideals it must have represented to those who first thought of it eons ago must have been far nobler than the realities that are on exhibit today.  We cannot point exactly to particular individuals or group of original thinkers responsible for the actual birth of democracy but today we can identify who will be responsible for its demise while in the care of the most powerful nation presently.  It is going to be, “We, the People”.  It is us, the inheritors of its legacy, who will inflict a slow acting poison of a lingering death.  By ‘us’ I mean the people who today are going to be living and participating witnesses to a democratic system under assault. 

It was kings and despots and their reign of oppression that provided the fertile ground from which seedlings of democracy may have sprouted and enabled to grow and flourish.  Deaths and the stench of dying populations, the suffering of uncountable serfs and subjects, the collective discontent and social upheavals brought about the ascendance of an experimental cure against unfettered despotism and tyranny.

From the bowels of pure human thought was founded a practical system that worked; but alas, it now seems clear, only temporarily at every instance it was prescribed.  Many a civilized nation grew to become empires – from Greece to Rome to France to Spain to Great Britain and today America. From whence it came it journeyed through so many revisions, each one a little better than the first but at every instance it seemed that perfection was unattainable. The basis for that conclusion is that history, if it taught us anything, has shown that the system worked only for a while. So successfully at first that every nation that adopted it has astounded the rest of world at its rapid progress, achieving never-once-before-attained successes at wealth accumulation, power and prestige but only because the preceding custodian was not able to hold on to its own success brought on by the very same system.  It was as if democracy, like tyranny, had an inherent shelf life of just a few generations. If anything, the world we know – this only one that we have - was all along a laboratory looking to find a cure for its social and political maladies, succeeding many times but ultimately failing each time to maintain the successes.  If it had found success we would not today be hearing about “wars and rumors of war”, powerful nations’ inutility at mediating, solving, correcting errant regimes. And failing, it seems, from their basic custodial responsibilities at protecting the oppressed and the environment. But that is all history now and even as we speak, historians continue to debate and politicians discuss and argue about how best today’s “democracy” should be used, revised even more or all together ignored.  But how did nations get to lose it?  How did we get to this point today where if democracy were to be a platform from which unity is the main objective, it has now instead become a broken vessel? 

Today the most powerful emblem of democracy, self-ascribed or by recognition from millions around the world eager to come here or wishing they were already here, suffers from self-doubt from within, envy and derision from without, and threat of destruction from a few but dangerous subscribers to an ideology embodied in their collective aspirations toward “Death to America”.  It is not however from without that presents the most clear and present danger but from within. It is us who are the present day inheritors of the ideals that begun over a dozen generations ago - that the founders hoped would work, saw it succeed and kept faith that the beacon of light will stay lit forever – who are charged with the mission to keep an experiment going along a clear and unambiguous course that is mapped out by The Constitution.  

This democracy is a house divided, split almost at the middle between those who want to conserve whatever it was that were in the minds of those who signed the Declaration and co-wrote the prescription for future generations to adhere to, and those who believe that such prescription has malleable properties that can be stretched, cropped, adjusted and interpreted in ways that conform with the times, or some provisions scratched out a little bit for political and social conveniences. 

The debate is red hot today in anticipation of what many consider a pivotal moment in this country’s history – the 2016 presidential election.  But this democracy had already endured many pivotal moments, including one in 1861 that threatened to split it permanently at a cost of almost a million lives when the population was not anywhere near what it is today.   After saving itself from what could have been an early end to a youthful democracy, the nation, reborn, had been engaged in many wars hence, protecting other democracies, promoting the ideals of freedom, excising tyrants from their oppressive grip on defenseless population, again at the cost of many lives and huge amount of the national treasure but not without criticism from corners around the world and even from within its own citizens; the latter being a solid testament to the freedoms accorded every person in this country.

The country today has again become a battleground.  There will not be the killing fields of the past great internal war but the stakes could be far more critical to the democracy that the signers of the Constitution thought will go on forever.  If this democracy is threatened it will not be from a quick fatal blow but from small slashing wounds.  It will be from words, from moral erosion to excessive social liberties to the loosening of ethical and educational standards, to political discourses where language is getting coarser by the day, the curtailment of free speech by those who strive to silence anyone with opposing views, and political correctness that weakens rather than strengthens the core of an open democratic discussion.  All powerful nations from past histories that first benefited from the blessings of democracy ultimately lost their place in the world when the people themselves let go of  the will or wisdom to keep to the ideals that made their successes possible in the first place.  Why is that?  What happened to the rule of plurality?

A 100% plurality is obviously not an enduring condition but one can say that at some point it was possible for a group of people to aspire, to dream and work towards a single goal.  We can say that those on the Mayflower were of one mind when they set sail to go into the unknown across a vast ocean. Each ambition, each idea of how to go about conducting their lives may have nuanced but the general idea and direction were made taut by a solid rope, but of many strands perhaps, reaching from one continent to the other.  We can say that there was unanimity and a single purpose.  For the most part the ideals were supported and maintained through much of its history.

Fast forward to succeeding generations and the country saw small cracks, a splintering of sort, from those whose ideals ran counter to the original tenets that the founding fathers adhered to.  We can cite a few examples.  The country was founded on Judeo-Christian principles, so atheism and disrespect for the practice of religion was unheard of because it was coming from a small group of people.  Belief that marriage should be between a man and a woman was a bed 
rock of family values, abortion was not even an openly discussed recourse, single parenting was clearly less than a sliver of one per cent of how children were raised, and a permanent dole from government was not something to be proud of or even encouraged, etc.  Each of the cited examples was not even a blip on the political radar and social awareness in mid to late 20th century.  So what happened?

Proponents of those and a few other examples coalesced into a larger block by banding together their various “causes, ideologies and agenda” to present a common front even as the ideals they promoted were not necessarily related to or connected with each other.  The proponents of each cause understood that individually they can chip away a mere ten per cent or less from the political landscape but together they can be a coalition with a loud enough voice to influence 40-50% of the electorate, or at least get their agenda to the front row of every political debate stage.

The two-party-system is not necessarily a bad thing for democracy but during the last several election cycles, at least for five decades, each one had developed a solid base and if we are to believe the polls the split is right about 45-45 on average, fluctuating by 5-10 per cent per cycle, with about 15 per cent claiming to be independents. In other words, each election is decided by how the independent block wields its power.  There may have been occasions in state levels for the most part and only occasionally in the national election when massive defection occurred to decide the elections.

A democratic plurality of 60% or more is now almost a thing of the past. But it can happen this time because there is anger among the electorate.  Candidates could be stoking or even lighting the fires themselves and there lies the problem for this nation.  If we are not careful we will indeed become conspirators to the demise of a democratic process.

 Abraham Lincoln, after the last internal war this country had ever experienced, was almost pleading to the American people at Gettysburg when he said:

“The brave men, living and dead, who struggled here, have consecrated it, far above our poor power to add or detract. The world will little note, nor long remember what we say here, but it can never forget what they did here.”


There was indeed a very high price paid to keep this country together.  There will be a much higher price tag that will be amortized over the next generation of children and their children if we get it wrong this time.

No comments:

Post a Comment