Featured Post

“Mountains to Molehills”

“Men trip not on mountains, they trip on molehills” – Chinese proverb A dear friend in response to my last musing had requested tha...

Thursday, April 14, 2016

Election Promises of Another Rainbow



First let me, if I could, reprint below a portion of what I mused over a year ago, lamenting about the state of political promises and not yet thinking then at that time about the 2016 election.

The rainbow is one of nature’s most well-known dazzling displays of colors.  It is also one that dissipates as we get closer to it, or if we re-position ourselves from a different viewing location. If one promises free college tuition to anyone with a GPA of 2.5 (a “C”) and you know that the current Congress will be hard pressed to find paper for a bill to write it on, then it is promising something at the end of a rainbow. When you promise that you will do it alone because it is for the good of the people, it only presupposes that you are the only one with the best idea that others are oblivious to.

One thing that is for certain though is the feel good effect of a promise.  The one doing the promise feels good about it and the prospective recipient of the promises is buoyed by the thought. But let us not forget that it will take others to fulfill the promises and they may not be too happy with the whole idea.

The President lives in an island universe where the wealth of the people is represented by bowls of jelly beans.  There are a few big bowls and many smaller and even tinier bowls of jelly beans across the island universe.  The President wants some of the jelly beans from the bigger bowls to be moved to the smaller and tinier bowls even if only for one reason: That those with the big bowls can afford to give away some of their jelly beans.  Without adding a single jelly bean – the President does not create wealth – he wants to redistribute the jelly beans because that is best for the island universe.  Actually the main reason is this: Owners of the bowls of jelly beans, big and small, can cast only one vote each. The displeased owners of the big bowls are smaller in number while those with the smaller bowls are large. As any politician knows, one only has to get the approval of the many (the recipient of the redistributed jelly beans) and it is all right to get the ire of a few.

What we should always remember is that every time a politician promises “free”, someone other than the recipient has to pay for it. The other lesson is that there is nothing there at the end of a rainbow but an empty pot of promises.

Indeed the only certainty about election promises is that voters get it every four years. During each term the people get the same treatment that Charlie Brown gets from Lucy every time he sets out to kick the football. Lucy yanks it away every time for one good or one clever reason, and Charlie Brown, like the hapless electorate, tries again and again because that football looks so tantalizingly believable.

Election promises, like free speech, are guaranteed by the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.  Keeping promises and making them happen, however, are not guaranteed by the state, least of all by the elected politicians. Yet, why do we listen election cycle after election cycle?  There are several reasons. We voluntarily succumb to collective amnesia, cynicism dulls our senses, Pollyannic instincts get the better of us, or we no longer care.

So we have someone promising to bring greatness and jobs back to America, build a wall that a neighboring sovereign country will pay for and he will re-negotiate all bad deals already in the books and henceforth every country hosting a U.S. military base or under the U.S. protective umbrella will be charged a fee, or a service charge of some sort.  He promises further that as soon as the primaries are over he will be Mister Nice Guy and act presidential in every way for the general election. So it is an admission at least that he had not been so nice or a bit abrasive in his language and comportment. The promise to change is not trivial because that would be akin to a carnivore switching to become a vegetarian but, as incredibly implausible as that could be, he just might pull it off, if only because narcissism proved to be the only valid winning ticket the last time the presidency was won.

The socialist candidate’s free everything (college tuition to healthcare) inducement is not just promising a rainbow but a full spectrum of and everything under the sun, including perhaps as yet to be revealed social visions toward income equality the public has not heard about.  Big banks and Wall Street are the big bad wolves and the candidate believes they’ve let loose among a herd of sheep.  This is not saying much, let alone something good, about the American electorate. They are deemed so helpless that only the benevolence of government is the answer to every conceivable social ailment.  What is so vexing about socialism is that it requires that wealth from capitalists be distributed to the poor. That is their go-to-well without realizing that when the water runs out of that well there may not be enough to dig deeper or to dig for more wells. That’s what capitalists do – dig for more wells because there is money to be made if capital is re-invested and in the process employ people to dig the wells. If the money runs out or the incentive is lost then who will the politicians call to provide water for everyone?

We have another who seems to have a veritable record of accomplishments in Ohio.  Unfortunately the folks do not see it because all that is in plain sight is the ant hill even though there is so much activity going on underneath.  The candidate is disadvantaged if his personality is defined by the image of an ant hill as seen from afar.  So he won only one state, his home state.  We therefore see the proverbial ant hill demolished by the proverbial elephant in the narrowing room of three candidates.

The Constitutionalist is running surprisingly strong in second place despite the fact that the subject of the Constitution seems an anachronism in the modern “liberated” nation of today.  This is despite the current two-term president who taught Constitutional Law and a Supreme Court whose role to clarify and interpret the Constitution thus far has managed only to shroud it with a hazy pall.  The criticism is not from anyone’s Constitutional expertise but from two different and opposing reactions from both sides of the two-party political systems with consuming regularity. Perhaps it is time to treat the Constitution not as a living document but one as set by the original signers; or perhaps look to amend it through the Congress (by proxy through the people), rather than relying on the court’s interpretation.

Then we have one with the most experience. Unfortunately, it is one viewed with unfavorable and sometimes opaque references and visible suspicions, second only to the one whose grandiose plans are dimmed only by his self-ascribed personal grandeur. And it is plausible that the choices in the general election will narrow to the two.  So, what are we to make of a potentially historic milestone in American politics to elect the first female President?  Do we see a Margaret Thatcher, or a Golda Meyer? And can the nation afford to see if it is so.  Well, it is all rainbow that I see right now.  Promises of a pot of gold are no longer good enough but that’s all we have right now.

For more on socialism's argument for income equality, please click the heading at the top, "Mountains into Molehills" for a similar analogy.



No comments:

Post a Comment