Featured Post

“Mountains to Molehills”

“Men trip not on mountains, they trip on molehills” – Chinese proverb A dear friend in response to my last musing had requested tha...

Monday, April 18, 2016

Footprints of the Free Market System from Martha's Vineyard to Hershey and Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Footprints
A solemn view of a past battleground.

On a most recent car trip we found ourselves visiting three places that were next to each other as the crow flies in the same sector of the Northeast.  I found a connection between these three places in ways I personally thought were significant that may not be so apparent to others. Geographically – the obvious reason - it was no accident since we took a rented van from Logan Airport, in Boston, MA with a plan to wind ourselves down to a suburb of Maryland (just outside Baltimore) to visit the two grandsons, one of whom was turning one.  Interestingly as grandchildren turn birthdays year after year we can’t help but look back at the past for hints or clues as to what lies ahead for their generation.  It is only natural because the path ahead could very well be a continuation of endless footprints that have already been made on well-trodden roads behind.  We would like to think that because, surely, we find ourselves today comfortably enjoying where we are, in the greater global scheme of things, that is.  I find it very difficult to question bluntly, “How lucky did my family and I get to be living in a land such as this?”  Granted there will be many around the world whose countries they consider just as fortunately endowed who will argue that point but not all of them left one place from across the other side of the globe to settle at another and live a life that we’ve since realized is better than ten per cent of the rest of the world’s population.  Again, it is an arguable statistic but one cannot argue with personal experience.  So, what do the above title places have in common?  Each one has a story and a contribution to this country’s history and development that I will try to connect.

I go back to those footprints I mentioned earlier.  These points of interest are linked by uncounted steps along many paths, seemingly unplanned and uncoordinated, that somehow converged towards a future that today makes sense.  I know these can be said of many areas around the world too, however, these were the specific places we visited so allow me to confine the story around them and I hope you will agree on the significance.

(I think you can enlarge each photo by clicking on them).


Only way by car to Martha's Vineyard is by ferry from Cape Cod

March is still a bit chilly

Office of the ferry service at Martha's Vineyard



Hardly anyone was on the deck which at the peak of summer it could be standing room only
It is still imaginable that over 200 years ago people may have looked to the sea for whaling ships from this corner overlook at one tip of Martha's Vineyard
 


Martha’s Vineyard

This small island just barely detached from the mainland of Massachusetts, off Cape Cod, is today considered by many as the summer capital of the U.S. but largely viewed as a place where rich people go and the air of elitism seems to permeate the salty air.  It has been the playground of a few presidents and their families and a setting for a 1975 summer block buster, “Jaws”, followed by a sequel or two and some other spin-offs.  I must point out that the fictional place that Peter Benchley conjured in 1974 was a summer place called Amity but to everyone familiar with the East Coast, it was clearly Martha’s Vineyard that the author had in mind.  I understand that’s debatable but let’s leave it at that and let’s not even go into how it came to be called Martha’s Vineyard when there was no evidence grapes were ever grown there, less so even today.  You can always look it up but it will not be any clearer.

The island did not use to be such an extravagant place.  It could very well have been populated by people who must have had very salty dispositions, with leathery skin from too much sun, who were veterans of the sea, while others were notably seafaring captains of whaling ships.  Herman Melville’s Moby Dick was inspired by stories the author heard while in Nantucket nearby. The place depended on the residents’ livelihood from whale blubber.  This was at a time when oil for lamps and lubrication from whale blubber, shirt buttons from whale bones determined the island’s economy.  Alas, that industry was dealt a sudden death when crude oil – the one from the ground – replaced whale blubber as source for lighting lamps.  Crude oil, first drilled successfully in Pennsylvania, just a stone throw away not far from the adjoining state border, changed everything in the whaling industry (killed it in fact), but more so at Martha’s Vineyard.  That was significant an economic blow to the island’s dependence on the whaling industry. 

While it was considered a reversal of fortune it did not take long for the island’s prosperity to re-develop from the very same industry – petroleum – that put a death knell to whale blubber, but fortunately a critical existential reprieve for the whales.  As new wealth was created from the nearby state’s discovery of oil  so did the craving from the nouveau riche for pleasurable things like summer vacations, access to beaches and sailing activities associated with owning property on the island. The Vineyard quickly turned into an island paradise.  It was the ultimate showcase for capitalism and the free market system ruled by supply and demand.  It was the latter that enabled ordinary citizens like my wife and I to afford to stay in a hotel there at 25% the cost of what it would be at the peak summer season.  Demand from tourists is so meager in March where the supply of available hotel rooms is plenty that a $400 per night room during summer can be had for $98.  That’s the good part and as a bonus the few tourists like us had the run of the place without having to deal with traffic and people. So all the conceivable tourist spots can be covered within a day with ample time to aw and ah, take pictures, while leaving your car to straddle three parking spaces and there was nobody to chide you for it and a bee line to the restrooms would consist of one.  The bad part was that 90% of restaurants were closed. Depending on how one looks at it, which could be good was that tourist traps like souvenir shops were closed and street sellers of touristy merchandise were never in sight.  The bad too was that the weather was not summer balmy – light jacket was definitely required.  If you drive, which we did, the 45 minute ferry ride each way from Cape Cod to and from the island was orderly and stress free and the upper deck chairs were empty.  In a way, like all tourist places anywhere, the free market system works and because Martha’s Vineyard is no exception, ordinary citizens can stay in the very same rooms that only the wealthy can afford during summer.  The gripe that ordinary citizens are precluded from enjoying the island during summer is not a valid one because the rule of a free market system is dictated by supply and demand. The summer season is, simply put, a high demand period for the same number of rooms. Now, immediately after Labor Day, we are told, the island’s hotels become a lodger’s market again, all through winter and just before late spring the following year. It’s just supply and demand.


Lighthouses abound on the island

Harbor View Hotel (there are several so called captain's cottages behind that are part of the hotel complex with several more rooms each)

The last ice age shaped the geoegraphy

Recently, the West got a good glimpse at what it is like, in comparison, to live in a socialist state when the U.S. re-instated diplomatic relations with Cuba. Journalists and other observers were treated to a glaring juxtaposition of capitalism viewed side by side with socialism. The 5-Star hotel in Havana, which by the way charged 5-star rates per night, could not possibly get a ½ star rating in the U.S., assuming the hotel passes building and health inspections.  Half a century under socialism has neither served society nor improved the standard of living, nor has the political system been good to the people. Meanwhile, the Cuban people see daily along their horizon passing cruise ships loaded with tourists from the West. It used to be only the elite got to travel to exotic places. Investors, if we prefer not to use the dreaded word, “capitalists”, put money into building commercial ships. Today competition between many cruise lines allowed for ordinary citizens to enjoy luxury travel.  In fact, if we go back to early 1900's when only the rich got to “cruise”, today’s ordinary travelers actually get far better amenities and definitely more savory meals in today’s ships than before.  That is capitalism.




While Hersey dominates the chocolate story of Pennsylvania we were first lured to a Russel Stover Candy store along the way


Hersey, Pennsylvania

Milton Hersey was four years old when the Civil War began.  He was born in the township of Derry, PA, not too far away from Gettysburg.  It was a misfortune of sort that changed the direction of his life early on.  He apprenticed at a printing company where he was fired on a minor mistake.  Although his father got the owner to re-instate him he followed the advice of his aunt to learn instead the art of making candy.  He only had a fourth grade education but his nose for the business guided him along a very circuitous path, even by today’s standards.  It can be said that even with that primary education he went on to get a master’s, or even a PhD from the universal schools of the practical and the real world of business. He learned candy making from a faraway place like Denver CO after some business failure from a candy business, later started his own business in Philadelphia, went to New York where the venture he started there lasted for three years. Like many success stories, Hersey’s footprints in the beginning were smudges of failure, perhaps no different from Sam Walton’s and other entrepreneurs who failed but never stopped trying.


At the Hersey Museum the story on the post sums it all for Milton Hersey's story.


Then as now the free market system had been and is still a stormy sea.  The ocean floor may be littered with corpses of failed businesses but it is the exceptional individual who strives and struggle, learn new swim strokes and method of survival who will remain afloat.  That is exactly what Hersey did.  He sold a caramel factory, bought land just 30 miles away where he wisely realized that a fresh and steady supply of cow’s milk was necessary to his new venture of chocolate making – which was an art borne out of trial and error and lots of experimentation.  He strategically built his factory in the middle of dairy farms, followed by building housing for the employees. Soon a whole community was created. We were told by the Hersey Museum guide that it was the U.S. Postal Service that created the town of Hersey, separate from Derry, for ease of sorting and delivering mail to the community around the factory sites as workers and their families settled to live close to work.

The spread of the Hersey brand literally covered the globe when during WWII the bars of chocolate symbolized America’s generosity when American GI's handed them out to war-weary civilians and their children as they liberated towns and cities one after another from Europe to the Pacific.


Milton Hersey depicted on a painting with young children who were and are still beneficiaries of his charity. 

At the main lobby of the Hersey Museum.

Chocolate making before mechanization

Capitalism in this case built a town and a university and a research hospital from out of grazing lands because someone had the entrepreneurial vision to make and sell chocolate.  Milton Hersey whose wife passed away at a young age did not have children so he bequeathed his fortunes, worth $60 million at that time in 1915, to an orphanage and today the Milton Hersey School, a private school, still does what Milton Hersey wanted to do from the beginning. It is a top notch school for children who live on campus provided with everything from clothing, meals, school supply and medical care free of charge from kinder to 12th grade to qualified students from low income families. Now we have the Milton S. Hershey Medical Center, part of Penn State Health and a top notch medical research facility.  Hersey’s money is still very much at work and is proof that capitalism is not such a bad idea.



Civil War Museum in Harrisburg, PA
Main lobby of the museum and stair case leading to 2nd floor.


Reprinted on a plaque was one many thousands of letters written by soldiers who fought during the war which says it all - the brutality of such an internal conflict.
Gettysburg


This view gives the scope of the battlefield














Everything that can be said of the great internal war had already been spoken, written about, dissected and debated but to no end; but the seemingly never ending discussion focuses on “why?” I am not about to add anymore to that, except to wonder whether the Civil War was necessary at all.  Unfortunately, the answer will have to depend on what truly caused it.  Many believed there were a few reasons the war broke out but invariably slavery was the main one.



If slavery was like an oozing cancer that seeped through from civilization to civilization over many centuries, imagining it like a blob spreading its way of subjugating and oppressing, it started to successively slow down by generation to generation.  We can say that that blob may have been stopped in its tracks after the Emancipation Proclamation.  That was an extraordinary event and the beginning of slavery’s end although, undeniably, there were pockets of it still in faraway places that have yet to be corrected at that time and today it is abhorred and viewed as uncivilized and immoral.


We must admit, however, that slave labor was an economically driven phenomenon.  When pharaohs and emperors and kings used forced labor the bottom line had always been economics.  The building of monuments, bridges, roads, fortifications, etc. were all managed as economic endeavors by rulers over the ruled because labor was a major component of every project.  Slave labor had been around for thousands of years. The accelerated growth of civilization was fueled by economics. Economic growth during the pre-industrial era was directly a measure of how intensely manual labor was acquired to support an ever burgeoning need for food production and material at ever expanding scales as a result of population explosion.



Throughout history slave labor was one of the rewards gained by victors of war who realized that capturing prisoners made more strategic sense than killing entire population of conquered land. Even as late as WWII the Geneva Convention allowed for captors to employ captives to provide labor, with certain guidelines of course, but there was no question it was all right to put prisoners of war to work. Slaves were not seen in the West as captives of war, or even defined by history as such, but many were indeed prisoners of tribal wars in a faraway place and sold to human traders who brokered the transfer to fill the need for labor in the new land.  This is a harsh pronouncement but bear with me because the point I’m making is that given time, slavery would have ended naturally in another twenty to fifty years at the most, culminating in the late 1800's without bloodshed.

By late 19th to early 20th century the Industrial Revolution that started in Europe was a powerful gathering wave of mechanization and machines taking over from human labor followed by a history- changing shift in employment, from agrarian economics to factory mass production of goods.  It would have followed that tobacco and cotton plantation owners would have been forced to use machines in order to compete. There was no way a slave-owning plantation owner would have continued with slave labor if the adjoining lands were being tended to by machines.  In fact, when much of labor was 40% agrarian at the turn of the 20th century, it is now a mere 2%.  A machine operated by one person is able to do what used to require perhaps a hundred people.

One would say this is revisionist speculation of could’ve, would’ve.  Slavery, at that time, in America in particular, had no other trajectory but to succumb to the pressure of modernization; perhaps one may conclude that the Civil War merely hastened the process.  The argument that machines were invented in lieu of slave labor is not a valid one.  Machines are just simply more superior, more powerful tools for doing work at never before achieved efficiency.  The driver of economic development has always been about producing goods at the lowest possible cost.  It is still true today as robots in the automotive industry are taking over much of the work, including those believed at first as only humans could do, i.e. welding and even assembling operations. Machines do it with repeatable accuracy at very reliable and sustainable level of peak performance across the entire work schedule. I conclude that slave labor was going to be extinguished in just a matter of time, Civil War or not, regardless of any speculation as to what really caused the war in the first place.
 
This is not to say that the Gettysburg Military Memorial is not to be consecrated or noted less, which worried Abraham Lincoln during his address there.  Gettysburg remains a hallowed place and everyone who died there, from both sides, should forever have a place at the altar of liberty.  Every freedom-loving citizen of this country is blessed to live here because ample sacrifices have already been made to secure that freedom. A visit to Gettysburg is the least we can do in return.  Those visiting from abroad find Gettysburg as compelling proof of the cost of resolving a conflict from within with force that devastated the land as brother fought against brother. It was a hard and unforgiving lesson although historians and ordinary people still debate about what has truly been learned.  

Even as I offer the speculative musing that the Civil War may not have been necessary because had the young country been allowed another generation or two the main cause for the conflict may have been eliminated had the natural course of the eventual abolition of slavery from social and technological pressures alone been allowed to happen.  In either case the world will still have to acknowledge that perhaps institutional slavery may have drawn its last breath here. This country had since held up the torch of freedom and it must never tire or lose the desire to show it for every corner of the world to see.


We took a self guided tour in our vehicle after securing a map from the Visitor Center. The Park Service  provides the map that shows the order of travel and there are orange colored arrows and numbered that tourists can follow along the many stops with plaque and statues and monument that explain every point of interest.

Perhaps much about emergency medical care, including amputations on the field hospitals and all kinds of immediate procedures on injured soldiers were learned there.

Without that many tourists we took the time without being rushed to see almost every significant stops and markers. Here the Memorial took to heart what Abraham Lincoln worried about - that the world "will little note nor long remember" of that day in Gettysburg 













No comments:

Post a Comment