Featured Post

“Mountains to Molehills”

“Men trip not on mountains, they trip on molehills” – Chinese proverb A dear friend in response to my last musing had requested tha...

Tuesday, June 7, 2016

Choice 2016 - “Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea”


The 2016 U.S. Presidential Election is shaping to be – if political pundits are to be believed – a choice between the lesser of two bad choices.  That is putting it mildly and gently, if polls are to have any kind of sustainable bearing until November.  The above title was a song written by Ted Koehler and Harold Arlen, and recorded by Cab Calloway in 1931.  Before we get too immersed into the artesian well of metaphors and cliché, it must first be made clear that the proper idiomatic expression is actually, “Between the devil and the deep sea”, but obviously the creators of the song, as most composers are wont to do, added a word to stretch the lyrics to fit the melody by adding blue between deep and sea.  It sounded good and the blue sea just makes sense in light of the romantic pop music genre.

But there is more quirkiness to it than the seemingly obvious but odd moral meaning to the expression. One must ask what in the devil has the devil got to do with the deep sea.  Well, “my capable research staff” found out that the deep sea being a nautical phrase, the devil was an old term to describe the ship’s longest seam in its hull.

“Originally, this expression described one of the unpleasant tasks aboard a wooden ship. The devil was the ship's longest seam in the hull. Caulking was done with pay or pitch (a kind of tar or asphalt). The task of 'paying the devil' (caulking the longest seam) by squatting in the bilges was one of the worst and most difficult jobs onboard. The term has come to mean a difficult, seemingly impossible task: 'The devil to pay and no hot pitch/aspahlt'. Landlubbers, having no seafaring knowledge, assumed it referred to satan and gave the term a moral interpretation.”

It came to be that the task of working the devil on a ship or get thrown overboard into the deep sea were both difficult if not devilishly unpleasant choices.

And so it is that, as it happens, we are told, the two presumptive nominees for President have higher negative ratings than their positive attributes.  Significantly too, if we are to believe those who claim to know, this will persist until election time.  What then is the electorate to make of all these?

Should the voters resign to the idea that they are choosing between the lesser of two evil?  This might seem just merely capricious or facetious; however, there is a very serious consequence.  This is like going to the casino with the given notion that one accepts to lose money but that the goal is not to lose too much.  And that is exactly what the people will be forced to do – gamble with the future of the country for the next four years and cross their fingers that the loss will not be too much. Unfortunately, however we look at it, or try hard to give it some kind of positive context, the result is likely a desperate one, with an outside chance of being catastrophic.  It is true because a fair number of folks are actually saying, in no uncertain terms, that they are voting for one because they cannot stand the thought of the other winning.  In effect, to borrow from "Survivor", the reality show (this election could actually be one), the voters are voting to banish somebody off the tribal council – not selecting someone to lead the tribal council.  

Of course, it is not true that every voter feels the same way.  After all, each candidate has a solid “no matter what” base, albeit at an estimated range of merely 35-40% of the general voting population, according to the generally accepted poll numbers (which change from one day to the next).  It is believed, however, that each base of supporters may not exceed 50%. More importantly, a good chunk of the base may actually be making the choice because given the alternative they’re willing to cast the die (“alea acta est”, informally translated, the die is cast, as when Julius Caesar was about to cross the Rubicon River) to root against one and decidedly not for the other. Then, the swing voters, the independents, libertarians and the uncommitted will play their most important role – direct their votes to swing the balance between the solid bases of each candidate. 

The “no-matter-what” supporters, therefore, do not have a problem; it is the swing voters who are the ones to grapple with the “horns of the dilemma”.  And those horns have gotten more sharp and pointed.  And to complicate matters, the horns apparently do not belong to the same bull.  One horn may be on one bull at one corral while the other could be on one entirely different animal at another stockade from a different zip code even.  How do these voters grab the horns of the dilemma, so far apart from each other, to wrestle with the decision? That is how divided both sides are and how alarmingly wide the chasm seems to have become.  And almost as inconceivably frightening, the fate of the nation’s future Commander-in-Chief will depend on the decision of 10%, perhaps 15 % of the electorate That’s how it seems but, of course, it is the cumulative total votes that does decide.  But it is so perversely incomprehensible that the division had gotten so badly ingrained that the result of the election is to be determined by a sliver of the voting population.

And what a choice!  What are we to make of the issues each candidate stands for when what comes barreling down the voter’s intellectual forehead are words of “untrustworthiness, perceived questionable honesty from one side, and from the other, extreme over-the-top narcissism, repeating words from a shallow vocabulary, personal insults, and incoherent direction of a campaign that manages to insult the very people who could potentially help to win an election. The phenomenon created by the two presumptive nominees seems to come out of a plot for a TV mini-series. The voters are faced with the reality of a flawed political legacy from a history of almost Shakespearean or Greek tragedies; or a successful reality TV show about a flawed self-promoter with an ego of a 58-story skyscraper.  Or, they are faced with the continuation of a master plan that had been in the works for the last seven years, or a new promise to make the country great again, with an inwardly looking agenda, defined metaphorically by an obsession with a wall.  It is one thing to enforce the integrity of a national border to allow only legal immigration but it is another to guarantee that the border country from which one perceives the bulk of illegal entry comes from to pay for the wall. For one thing the southern neighbor can ill afford to build the wall and, as “an art of a deal”, or as a practical matter, what’s in it for Mexico?  Granted that is just an opening bid towards a goal to negotiate a sound resolution but should one begin with an awful rhetoric and along with it hurl ethnic insults in a scatter-shot manner?

On the other hand, what promise can ever be presented to the voters from a candidate whose likability index hovered at near ground level of the chart and constantly reeling from questions on her ability to keep things honest or her proclivity to stretch the truth for political expediency? We have one with a perceived inability to disassociate what is false from the truth. Then we have the other whose critics attribute a dissociative affliction of being a super ego, but does something that is politically self destructive: attacking the judge of Mexican descent who has jurisdiction over a relatively inconsequential civil suit, focusing on such when there is so much to discuss about the economy and direction of the country in general.

If there ever was a good example of being caught between a rock and a hard place, the polling place in November is one.

There is the dilemma but the voters must know of an obscure word - trilemma - from the same Latin root word.  It is what brought the most recent ascendance of a third party.  But we all know the futility of it.  It has its proponents and then there is this – the trilemma voters who will stay home, or opt out of going to the polls so as not to choose between the devil and the deep blue sea. Are you going to pick one over the other or impale yourself with the third horn of a trilemma?



No comments:

Post a Comment